Type your search terms above and press Enter to see the search results.

  • Back Issues
    • The Tasveer Journal: Publication & Exhibition
    • #04 Performace
    • #05 Popular Culture
    • #06 Subjects & Spaces
    • #07 Architecture
    • #08 Diaspora
    • #09 Fashion & Textiles
    • #10 Electoral Politics
    • #11 Minorities
    • #12 Faith and the City
    • #13 Architectural Forms & Subtexts
    • #14 TFA-Tasveer Emerging Photographers
    • #15 Bollywood Flashbacks
    • #16 Sneak Peek: Delhi Photo Festival 2015
    • #17 Playtime
    • #18 Forms of Discrimination
    • #19 New Lands
    • #20 Alchemy
    • #21 Of Gods & Men
  • Archive
  • About
  • Contact
  • Visit the Tasveer Bookstore

Tasveer Journal

  • Back Issues
    • The Tasveer Journal: Publication & Exhibition
    • #04 Performace
    • #05 Popular Culture
    • #06 Subjects & Spaces
    • #07 Architecture
    • #08 Diaspora
    • #09 Fashion & Textiles
    • #10 Electoral Politics
    • #11 Minorities
    • #12 Faith and the City
    • #13 Architectural Forms & Subtexts
    • #14 TFA-Tasveer Emerging Photographers
    • #15 Bollywood Flashbacks
    • #16 Sneak Peek: Delhi Photo Festival 2015
    • #17 Playtime
    • #18 Forms of Discrimination
    • #19 New Lands
    • #20 Alchemy
    • #21 Of Gods & Men
  • Archive
  • About
  • Contact
  • Visit the Tasveer Bookstore

Looking Back: A Colonial Ethnographic Portrait of South India

K Rangachari

Published August 26, 2014 by Shilpa Vijayakrishnan
SHARE
FacebookTwitterPinterest
Kapu Bride and Bridegroom, from Vol. III of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Kapu Bride and Bridegroom, from Vol. III of the Castes and Tribes of South India

The representation of minority communities is a contentious issue that often comes up in modern anthropological contexts. In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries though, anthropological and ethnographical studies, situated as they were in a climate that prized empiricism as the key to knowledge and rationality were less interested in the problems associated with ‘accurate renditions’ and the difficulties of portraying the nuances and subtleties that govern the identities of peoples – and more focussed on gathering data. Claiming a superior objectivity that is difficult to argue in a postmodern world, these anthropologists, being products of their time, worked within a binary – constantly producing the ‘Other’ as an inferior subject.

Chenchu dance, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Chenchu dance, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Tiya woman from Vol. VII of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Tiya woman from Vol. VII of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Chenchu, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Chenchu, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

The British colonial project in India was unsurprisingly, deeply invested in gathering information. Extensive surveys were carried out, and with the advent of photography, the camera was heavily employed as a means to record not just topography and terrain, but also the ‘natives’. Much has been written, in recent times, on the ways in which knowledge (and the lens, in this context) was used to impose control and order over a foreign country.

The European colonial project is a complex construct that functioned within a framework of racial and cultural superiority, as also a spiritual, economic, technological and political hierarchy.  Early anthropology was closely linked to anthropometry – a belief that anatomical measurements (especially those of the cranium, as being the reservoir of the brain – the primary rational organ) revealed an individual’s intelligence, personality and character. This helped provide colonisers justifications for their perceived superiority. Colonised natives were often stigmatised for their small skull sizes and other ‘unfavourable’ physiognomical characteristics – producing a narrative of what today is termed, scientific racism.

Edgar Thurston introduces his seven volume tome the Castes and Tribes of Southern India, first published in 1909 and intended to be an encyclopaedia of sorts of the social groups living in the Madras Presidency and the erstwhile princely states of Travencore, Mysore, Coorg and Puddokottai, with a discussion on prevailing theories of anthropometry and craniometry and tables of data culled from his own fieldwork.

a. European Skull b. Hindu Skull, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

a. European Skull b. Hindu Skull, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Thurston, the superintendent of the Madras Museum was assisted by K Rangachari, also an employee of the museum to traverse South India in an attempt to collate information and produce an ethnographic portrait of its people by providing descriptions of their physiognomy, rituals, religious beliefs, social traditions and communal practices.

It is interesting to note that the photographs that illustrate this work are contributions of Rangachari and point to the difficulties associated with access. Thurston himself, points out for instance, that “In carrying out the anthropometric portion of the survey, it was unfortunately impossible to disguise the fact that I am a Government official, and very considerable difficulties were encountered owing to the wickedness of the people, and their timidity and fear of increased taxation, plague inoculation, and transportation. The Paniyan women of the Wynaad believed that I was going to have the finest specimens among them stuffed for the Madras Museum.”

Paniyan, from Vol. VI of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Paniyan, from Vol. VI of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Gamallas, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Gamallas, from Vol. II of the Castes and Tribes of South India

One of the primary ethical issues raised in discussions surrounding colonial ethnography, is that of gaze; one that disclaimed any right of the colonised native to privacy, or self-representation. In the photographs that accompany these seven volumes, there are a number that fall into the problematic of producing subjects as exoticised fantasies, or imagined barbarians – reflecting the text that relies in equal measure on pseudoscience and anecdotes to produce this narrative.

Telugu Brahman with Rudraksha Coat, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Telugu Brahman with Rudraksha Coat, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Bairagis, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Bairagis, from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Vakkaliga bride, from Vol. V of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Vakkaliga bride, from Vol. V of the Castes and Tribes of South India

The conventions of colonial ethnographic portraits revolved around the display of traditional clothing, rituals or professions. And while this is the normative format in most of the images that illustrate this text, one must note that unlike many other photographs of its kind, the subjects in these tend to be far more comfortable, staring directly back at the lens, in some cases even defiantly so – or posing for the photographer, perhaps because he is Indian, and in many ways therefore, much more of an insider.

One even observes photographs, were the subjects seem entirely indifferent to the camera absorbed in their own activities, and wonders, romantically whether it displays a moment of inversed power relations, or cynically whether they were captured without their knowledge or assent.

Nayadis making fire, from Vol. V of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Nayadis making fire, from Vol. V of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Jangam, from Vol. IV of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Jangam, from Vol. IV of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Oriya Brahman from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Oriya Brahman from Vol. I of the Castes and Tribes of South India

Questioning the use of the camera as a means of control and imaging, modern postcolonial theory has deconstructed the ways in which documentation was used to image and (re)present communities. The pioneering British administrators-ethnographers produced a great number of survey reports and documents that served as a source of invaluable information about varied regions and peoples – their rituals, religious beliefs, social traditions and communal practices. At the same time, this information was used to promote colonial agendas and usually constructed the native as a backward, primitive savage.

Although these ethnographers operated under a certain subjective bias that is by and large visible in all of their writing, rendering them obsolete in contemporary times, they help us articulate the politics, and refigure the limitations, of representation.

 

– Shilpa Vijayakrishnan

 


Images: From the Castes and Tribes of South India, taken from print editions in the public domain. Digital copies of the entire seven volumes are available at the Gutenberg Library.

SHARE
FacebookTwitterPinterest
Previous Post:Footnotes in History: Being Anglo IndianNext Post:Book Review: The Vanishing Kodavas

Sidhpur: Time Present Time Past

Sebastian Cortés

Published August 08, 2014

Book Review: When Abba Was Ill

Afsha Khan

Published March 02, 2014

Change of Course

Prasiit Sthapit

Published September 27, 2013

Follow

Connect with us.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Newsletter

Sign up for our latest posts and updates.
Tasveer Arts Pvt. Ltd.
Sua House 26/1 Kasturba Cross Road
Bangalore 560001, India

+ 91 80 40535303/217
info@tasveerarts.com
+Our Privacy Policy

www.tasveerjournal.com. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2019 Tasveer Journal ·